I back Mitchell's decision to pull her music from Spotify
For a while now, I make a deliberate effort to listen to a broader selection of music. Every other night, when cleaning the kitchen (the Man and I take turns putting Daughter to bed), I choose something new to listen to. New to me, that is. Two nights ago I was listening to an album of Joni Mitchell through Spotify. I heard some of her music, but never actually listened to a whole album. I liked it and the songs captured my somewhat gloomy mood.
Yesterday Mitchell announced she pulled all of her songs from Spotify and when mindlessly hitting the play button on my Sonos speaker in the kitchen this evening, it played the cached seconds of Mitchell’s song and then stopped. The songs are indeed offline. Mitchell follows the lead of Neil Young, who made a statement against the platform for hosting a white male podcaster with dubious content and attracts lots of listeners with that.
As I’m the producer of a podcast myself, I’m well aware of Spotify’s quest to draw podcasters in. Podcasts are the new content goldmine for selling ads and subscriptions. I made the effort of connecting my podcast hosting service to Spotify, but I can tell you that almost no-one listens to my podcast through Spotify. I guess that is the case for most podcasts, since lately the company is aggressively contracting successful podcasters to exclusively stream on Spotify. One of my favourite shows for instance, Science Vs is exclusively streaming on Spotify after its producing company Gimlet signed a deal with them. As a result, I don’t listen to show as my main source for checking for new episodes is the podcast app on my iPhone.
It’s one thing to provide a platform for all podcast producers, next to your core business of music streaming. It’s a totally different thing to pay a podcaster that produces controversial content a huge amount of money to stream exclusively on your platform. So yes, I totally understand Young and Mitchell’s reaction. By signing that deal, Spotify puts a stamp of approval on the show they bought. The content of the podcast is now linked to the brand Spotify. I never associate the content of a podcast with the brand Apple, but every podcast exclusively streaming on Spotify does rub of on the brand Spotify. I don’t think they put enough thought into the side-effects of signing a deal with a controversial podcaster.
As a result, I can’t listen to more of Mitchell’s music tonight. I can live with that for now, but by withdrawing her music, Mitchell does make me reflect on Spotify’s position in this world and whether they deserve my subscription fee. Planting lots of little seeds of doubt can topple big brands in the end.
Klik voor reacties
Zie je hier geen reactieformulier verschijnen? Sommige browsers en privacy-instellingen (bijv. tracking-bescherming of adblockers) blokkeren dit onderdeel standaard, omdat het van een ander domein wordt geladen. Probeer in dat geval tracking-bescherming voor deze site tijdelijk uit te schakelen, of open de pagina in een andere browser.
Vermeldingen elders op het web
Heb je op dit artikel gereageerd? Stuur een webmention: